Custom Orthotics vs. Good Feet Store Insoles: Which Is Better for Foot Pain?

If you’re dealing with foot pain, plantar fasciitis, or arch problems, you’ve probably considered orthotics to relieve discomfort and improve mobility. Many people turn to Good Feet store insoles, but are they the best solution? While they provide a quick, one-size-fits-all approach, custom orthotics prescribed by our podiatrists offer tailored support that addresses the root cause of your foot pain—often at a better value.

Let’s explore why custom orthotics from Premier Podiatry P.C. are ​​a superior choice over Good Feet store insoles.

1. Custom Orthotics Are Designed Specifically for Your Feet

One of the biggest advantages of custom orthotics is their precise fit. When you visit our specialized team, they conduct a biomechanical assessment, gait analysis, and foot mold impression to create orthotics that match your foot structure, walking pattern, and unique pressure points.

In contrast, Good Feet store insoles come in pre-made arch styles that may not fit your exact needs. Store associates may recommend an insole based on a general foot scan, but this lacks the precision of a medical evaluation. The wrong fit can lead to uneven pressure distribution, worsening foot pain instead of relieving it.

Why This Matters for Foot Conditions

Custom orthotics are especially beneficial for people with:

• Plantar fasciitis – Provides targeted arch support to ease heel pain
• Flat feet – Helps restore natural arch positioning
• Bunions & hammertoes – Reduces strain on joints and prevents worsening deformities
• Diabetic foot pain – Reduces pressure points to prevent ulcers
• Arthritis – Improves balance and alleviates joint pain

2. Custom Orthotics Are Often Covered by Insurance – Good Feet Store Insoles Are Not

Two of the most overlooked factors in the custom orthotics vs. Good Feet insoles debate are cost and insurance coverage.

• Custom orthotics are often covered by insurance when prescribed by our podiatrists. Many insurance providers recognize orthotics as a medically necessary treatment for conditions like plantar fasciitis, arthritis, and diabetic foot complications. Patients typically pay only a copay or deductible rather than the full price.
• Good Feet store insoles are not covered by insurance because they are considered over-the-counter, non-prescription inserts. This means you must pay the full amount out of pocket.

Cost Breakdown:

• Custom orthotics (with insurance) – Patients may pay $50–$200 depending on their insurance plan.
• Custom orthotics (without insurance) – Typically range from $300–$600, but last for several years.
• Good Feet store insoles – Can cost $400–$1,000 per pair, often requiring multiple sets for different shoe types, making them even more expensive than custom orthotics.

The Hidden Cost of Good Feet Store Insoles

Many customers are shocked to learn that Good Feet insoles are non-refundable, even if they don’t work. With custom orthotics, you can return for adjustments or replacements through our podiatrist if the fit isn’t perfect.

3. Long-Term Durability and Cost-Effectiveness

• Custom orthotics are made from high-quality medical-grade materials designed to last 2–5 years. They maintain their shape and support even with regular use.
• Good Feet store insoles typically wear out within 6–12 months and need frequent replacements. The lack of durable, high-performance materials means their arch support can flatten over time, reducing effectiveness.

Investing in a high-quality custom orthotic may save you money in the long run. Instead of replacing store-bought insoles multiple times a year, a one-time investment in custom orthotics provides years of reliable support.

4. Podiatrist Expertise & Adjustments vs. Sales-Driven Recommendations

At Premier Podiatry P.C., our podiatrists provide:

• Professional evaluation – A detailed foot exam, gait analysis, and 3D mold impressions ensure a perfect fit.
• Ongoing care – If your orthotics feel uncomfortable or your foot structure changes, we can adjust or replace them as needed.
• Medical-grade materials – Unlike the generic plastic and foam used in store-bought insoles, custom orthotics use durable, medical-grade components tailored for long-term wear.

In comparison, Good Feet stores employ sales associates, not medical professionals. Their recommendations are based on in-store scans and sales tactics, not clinical assessments. Without medical expertise, they cannot diagnose foot conditions or make necessary adjustments for proper support.

5. Local, Expert Care from our Trusted Podiatrists

If you’re looking for custom orthotics near you, choosing our podiatrist-designed orthotic from Premier Podiatry P.C. is the best decision for your foot health. Unlike store-bought options, our orthotics come with:

• Personalized fitting and expert guidance
• Adjustments and modifications for ongoing comfort
• Insurance coverage options to reduce out-of-pocket costs

Serving Ebensburg and surrounding areas, we specialize in custom orthotics for all ages and foot conditions.

Final Verdict: Custom Orthotics Are the Best Investment for Your Feet

While Good Feet store insoles may offer quick relief, they lack the customized support, medical precision, durability, and insurance coverage of podiatrist-prescribed orthotics.

• Custom orthotics are tailored to your exact needs.
• They last longer and provide better support.
• Most insurance plans cover them, saving you money.
• Adjustments are available to ensure a perfect fit.

Don’t settle for generic insoles—get the expert care your feet deserve! Schedule an appointment with Premier Podiatry P.C. today to explore custom orthotics and step into pain-free living.